Pizza Secret

The story

Crafted with passion, served with love

A Brooklyn Address with Roman Credentials

Pizza Secret sits on 5th Avenue in Brooklyn, and its name is on the Gambero Rosso radar — earning 2 Slices in the 2026 edition of the guide, the Italian authority's benchmark for pizza excellence outside Italy. That kind of recognition doesn't come without a product worth seeking out.

Beyond that, the source material available is limited, so rather than fill the page with assumptions, the honest note is this: Pizza Secret is a pizza destination in Brooklyn that has caught the attention of one of the most respected voices in Italian food criticism. For a spot on 5th Ave in New York City, that is a meaningful signal.